Star Trek Zero – Where No Man Should Have Gone Before or After
Note: There are some spoilers in this article. So if you plan on seeing the movie you might not want to read this.
A couple of nights ago my sweetie and I went to see the new Star Trek movie, Star Trek Zero (STZ). This movie did not pass what I call “The Cynthia Butt Test.” Let me explain: if, while watching a movie I start to fidget in my seat and am aware of my butt falling asleep or feeling uncomfortable, it is because the movie is not holding my interest. If I go through a whole movie without being aware of said butt, then I know that the movie is a winner. I started to be aware of my butt 15 minutes into this movie.
Let me start by out by saying that being a teenager in the 60’s, I, like millions of others, fell in love with the series and characters that inhabited The Starship Enterprise. Most of us that enjoy Start Trek have seen all the episodes multiple times and have an understanding of the history of the characters, their personalities, their moral and ethical views, what makes them tick, what their strong points and weaknesses are, the role that their bonds of friendship and loyalties toward each other play in how they relate to each other, and let us not overlook the ever-important role that their mission plays – we were reminded of it at the opening of each and every episode.
So, having established that there is history here, the new STZ takes all of that and throws it out the Enterprise’s window (or porthole). The writers (Roberto Orci and Alex Kurtzman) show a total lack of integrity and imagination. I say this because a writer with integrity and imagination would have taken the time to do their homework and understand who the characters were, their history and the history of the Star Trek series, and within that framework, have come up with a plot that was faithful to that already established history and character development. Hey, this isn’t a new concept. Many writers take established characters like Sherlock Holmes or Nero Wolfe, and many other such well-known and loved fictional characters and write new stories and adventures that are imaginative, but true to the storyline and respectful of the established history and characterization that the original author has given his creation. STZ does none of that. It uses each and every one of the original characters and trashes them. The characterization in this movie of all the crew of the Starship Enterprise are at best caricatures, and not even good caricatures, or in many cases they are silly and cartoonish and unbelievable (see Doc Apple’s Cultural Corner article on this movie: Star Trek Zero – a Big Zero for Star Trek. In his article he does a great job of pointing out some specifics about plot and character faux pas with which this movie is replete).
I guess the writers must have thought that it was okay to turn Spock into a horny, emotionally, out of control and illogical Vulcan (what the hell is that about?), destroy the planet Vulcan (untrue in the series), turning Uhura into a sex object that both Kirk and Spock have the hots for (again, what the hell is that about?), making Kirk a jerk (guess they thought that just because those two words rhyme it was an okay idea), killing Spock’s mother (so who the hell is the Earth woman who appears in all those episodes as Spock’s mom?), having Chekov not be 5 years old (he was about 17 in the original series when the other characters are in their 30’s), making Scotty appear as a boob instead of the accomplished engineer he is supposed to be, and the list goes on and on and on.
This movie’s writing is so bad it is not even internally consistent. By that I mean that even if you take it as a stand-alone story and disregard your expectation that it should stay true to the original series, the movie isn’t even true to itself. In order for the movie to at least make any sense, the writers should have done what they promised when the old Spock in the movie tells Kirk that he can fix the timeline, and done so. If they had at the end of the movie had the Enterprise return to the beginning of the movie and the birth of Kirk, at least they would have redeemed some of the plot. Instead, they don’t even do that.
There are so many things that are wrong with this movie that it would take a book to point them all out. This movie totally failed The Cynthia Butt Test. What a pity and a missed opportunity. Going back to when these characters were young and starting out could have been such a good story. What a shame that the writers were too lazy and incompetent to do the story and the characters justice.













